| 1824 | William Fulton | 1910-1913 | Steve McCown *1913 | |
| 1825 | Caleb Bales | 1913-1914 | Roscoe Russell | |
| 1828-1832 | Charles Trowbridge | 1914-1916 | Martin G. Jones **1916 | |
| 1832-1834 | William Craig | 1916 | Harry E. Jones | |
| 1834-1838 | Allen Stroud | 1916-1920 | Morton Hollingsworth | |
| 1838-1842 | William Bales | 1920 | Alex C. Jones | |
| 1842-1846 | Charles Trowbridge | 1920 | James W. Thomas | |
| 1846-1848 | Owen Craig | 1920-1922 | Lewis Sweet | |
| 1848-1852 | Eli Newlin | 1922-1924 | Harry Newland | |
| 1852-1856 | William Potts | 1924-1928 | William Rein | |
| 1856-1860 | James Weller | 1928-1931 | Harry Newland | |
| 1860-1864 | Isaac Porter | 1932-1934 | Earl Smith | |
| 1864-1868 | Harvey D. Crane | 1936-1940 | Allen Hennis | |
| 1868-1872 | Jacob S. Stephens | 1940-1945 | Oel Potter | |
| 1872-1876 | Lewis H. Beckman | 1946-1948 | Loren Griffin | |
| 1876-1880 | Spencer H. Dallas | 1948-1958 | Dom Costello | |
| 1880-1884 | William C. Myers | 1958-1967 | Robert Lindsey | |
| 1884-1888 | John A. Darby | 1967-1974 | Frank Turchi | |
| 1888-1890 | William Rheuby | 1974-1979 | Jack Rauchbach | |
| 1890-1892 | Michael Maher | 1979-1982 | Frank Turchi | |
| 1892-1894 | Joseph C. Dillow | 1982-1990 | Kim H. Hawkins | |
| 1894-1898 | John M. Roberts | 1991-1994 | Larry J. Jones | |
| 1898-1900 | Frank Slater | 1995-1998 | Paul F. Curry | |
| 1900-1904 | James A. Swayne | 1999-2006 | Kim H. Hawkins | |
| 1904-1908 | Jacob S. Stephens | 2007-Present |
Robert J. Spence |
|
| 1908-1910 | Morton Hollingsworth | |||
| * Died in office | ** Killed in the line of duty |